How to Cook Mahi Mahi – Delicious and Easy Recipe

How to cook mahi mahi: Properly cooked mahi mahi is tender, flaky, and full of flavor. Adding a lemon garlic butter sauce makes it even better.1 Mahi mahi, known as dorado or dolphinfish, is a favorite white fish. It can be cooked in many ways like pan-searing, grilling, or baking. This recipe makes a top-notch meal in under 30 minutes.1 Seasoning the fish well and using both the stove and oven is the secret. This gives the fish a crispy outside and a juicy inside. No matter your cooking experience, this mahi mahi recipe will wow you.

A piece of fresh mahi-mahi fillet on a cutting board, surrounded by colorful vegetables like bell peppers, tomatoes, and onions. The fillet is seasoned with pepper, salt, and spices, with fresh sprigs of thyme and rosemary on top. In the background, a skillet is heating up on the stove.

Key Takeaways

  • Mahi mahi is a flavorful and versatile white fish that can be prepared in various ways
  • This easy recipe results in a restaurant-quality dish that can be made at home in under 30 minutes
  • The lemon garlic butter sauce is an outstanding accompaniment that complements the tender, flaky mahi mahi
  • The recipe is suitable for both experienced cooks and those new to preparing fish
  • Properly seasoning the fish and using the stovetop-to-oven cooking method are key to achieving the perfect texture and flavor

What is Mahi Mahi?

Mahi mahi is a fish you might see on restaurant menus. It’s also known as the common dolphinfish or dorado. You can find it in the waters of the Gulf of Mexico, Costa Rica, Hawaii, and the Indian Ocean.2Its name comes from Hawaii, where “mahi mahi” means “very strong”. This is because the fish moves like a dolphin.

Popular Fish Variety

Many people love mahi mahi for its taste and texture. It’s mild yet flavorful with a firm, moist flesh2. The author finds it’s great for any recipe and enjoys eating it too.

Mahi Mahi Origins

Mahi mahi, known also as the dorado, is fond of warm surface waters. It’s often seen in the Gulf of Mexico, Costa Rica, Hawaii, and the Indian Ocean2. It received its name, mahi mahi, from a Hawaiian phrase meaning “very strong” because it moves elegantly, like a dolphin.

Sustainability Concerns

The way mahi mahi is caught affects its sustainability. The Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch advises that mahi mahi caught in the U.S. Atlantic using certain methods is best. Fish caught in a certain way in the Eastern Central Pacific or by U.S., Ecuadorian, and Panamanian fleets are a good second choice. They say to steer clear of mahi mahi caught in other ways, from various oceans.

Learn More Recipe: How to Cook Pumpkin

How to Cook Mahi Mahi

Preparing the Fish

First, make the mahi mahi fillets dry by patting them with paper towels. This removes extra moisture and helps with searing.3 Then, season the fillets with salt and pepper or your favorite spices.

Pan-Searing Technique

To cook mahi mahi, start with the stovetop and move to the oven. Heat an oven-proof pan and add oil.2 Sear the fish until it’s golden on one side, then flip. Put the pan in a hot oven. Cook for about 5 minutes more, until the fish is just done.

Lemon Garlic Butter Sauce

As the mahi mahi bakes, make the lemon garlic butter sauce. Combine butter, garlic, herbs, and lemon in a pan.3 Melt this mix until it’s bubbling. Once the fish is ready, pour this sauce on top. It makes the dish deliciously tangy.

A mahi mahi fillet sizzling on a grill with bright grill marks, accompanied by a colorful mango salsa with diced red onion and cilantro. The fillet should have a golden brown crust and juicy white flesh inside, with a sprinkle of black pepper and sea salt. The background could show other summery ingredients like zucchini and bell peppers, along with some grill utensils nearby.

how to cook mahi mahi

Cooking mahi mahi is simple and yields a restaurant-quality result. Season fish fillets with salt and pepper. Then, sear them in a hot pan for a golden crust.3 Finish the cooking in the oven to make sure it’s done1. Finally, top the dish with a lemon garlic butter sauce1. This process guarantees a tender, flaky, and delicious mahi mahi meal.

A sizzling mahi mahi fillet in a pan with a sprinkle of herbs and spices. The fish is golden brown on the outside and moist and flaky on the inside. The pan is placed over a gas stove with blue flames in the background, adding a touch of warmth to the scene. The fillet is being gently flipped over with a spatula, revealing its perfectly cooked texture on both sides. Steam is rising from the pan, giving off a mouthwatering aroma that entices the senses.

Learn More Recipe: How to Cook Pork Ribs


Mahi mahi is known for being great for a seafood dinner that’s both quick and tasty. This recipe brings out the best in it. The fish stays tender and flaky, with a hint of sweetness, thanks to a lemon garlic butter sauce.4 Cooking mahi mahi this way makes it seem like you’re dining out, but you can do it right at home in just 30 minutes.4

It’s not just yummy; mahi mahi is nutritious too. It’s packed with important nutrients like phosphorus, B vitamins, and selenium,4 alongside healthy fats, protein, and other nutrients you need. Plus, it has antioxidants which help your body stay healthy, thanks to minerals like iron and magnesium.4

Whether you often cook fish or are giving it a first try, this recipe will wow everyone. The fish’s freshness pairs perfectly with a crispy sear and zesty lemon garlic sauce. It’s not only good to eat but pleasing to the eye.4 So, try making this mahi mahi dish tonight. You’ll savor a meal that tastes like it’s come from a top-notch restaurant, right in your own kitchen.

Learn More Recipe: How to Cook Bacon on Stove


What is mahi mahi?

Mahi mahi is a ray-finned fish found in Gulf of Mexico, Costa Rica, and more. Its Hawaiian name means “very strong”. This is because it moves like dolphins do.

Where does mahi mahi come from?

Many mahi mahi fish swim in the Gulf of Mexico, around Costa Rica, and Hawaii. They are also found in the Indian Ocean.

Is mahi mahi a sustainable seafood choice?

The best mahi mahi comes from the U.S. Atlantic, caught with handlines or trolling. It’s the top choice for sustainability. Mahi mahi from the Eastern Central Pacific is also good, caught with purse seine by some fleets. But, fish from the Atlantic, Pacific, and Indian Oceans might have issues. So, it’s best to avoid those.

How do you prepare mahi mahi for cooking?

First, pat the fillets dry with paper towels. This removes extra moisture for a better sear. Then, season them with salt and pepper. You can also use garlic powder or paprika.

What is the best way to cook mahi mahi?

To cook mahi mahi, use the stovetop-to-oven method. Heat a pan with oil until it’s hot. Cook the fillets on one side until browned. Then, finish them in a 400°F oven for about 5 minutes. Be careful not to overcook.

What sauce goes well with mahi mahi?

A lemon garlic butter sauce pairs perfectly. Melt butter in a pan with garlic, herbs, and lemon. Then, pour it over the cooked fish. Dish the juice from the pan too.

Learn More Recipe: How to Cook the Perfect Steak

By Eleanor

As a seasoned food recipe expert, I'm here to share my passion for creating delicious dishes. Join me in exploring exciting flavors, mastering techniques, and making cooking a joyful experience.